The Daughter-In-Law Rules: Review

I began to stand up for myself and she just couldn't handle it. It angered her and we bickered for over a year, but then eventually, I'm not sure when we found a little bit of common ground. We still often butt heads on many things and she still at times is very pushy and unaware of how selfish she can be, but I've learned along the way that for the most part, deep down inside she means well and though it doesn't come across that way to often I try not to let it bother me so much anymore.
Still I've been hoping for something to come along to help my MIL and I have a closer relationship, more of a mom daughter relationship, instead of just a common courtesy one. So when the opportunity to review The Daughter-In-Law Rules: 101 Surefire Ways to Manage (and Make Friends with) Your Mother-In-Law by Sally Shields came along I was excited. The book was a quick and simple read. I was able to read it in less than a week. I'm sure if I would have set my mind to it I could have read it in even less time.
My thoughts on the book?
I have mixed feelings about the book. Though I found many of the rules helpful I also felt that many of the rules required a sense of self-degradation or at other times fakeness in order to order to get a long with my MIL. I have a problem with that, because this is what I was trying to get away from. It is sad for me to think that the only way to get along with my MIL is to pretend to be someone I'm not by pretending to agree with everything she says just to make her happy (be fake) or my degrading myself (putting myself down to make her feel better about herself).
Of course, like many women, I have no desire of continuing to butt heads with MIL. Still I was hoping to do it by having an open and honest relationship with her. In doing so, I would accept her for who she is and she would accept me for who I am. Perhaps I am a dreamer to think this is ever possible, but this is my ultimate goal.
Fortunately this book did have some rules that I could work with and that would help me find common ground with my MIL. Examples of these good rules are: rules 2-7 and 35-38. There are others as well. I agree woman should not speak ill of their husbands to their MIL. Your MIL did give birth to your husband and if it weren’t for her he wouldn't be around. I agree that I should do my part calling her more often, making sure she receives a gift on special occasions, etc. I also agree that when spending the night at my MIL or anyone else's house, making your bed and wrapping your "dirty napkins" is extremely important and a sign of respect for others as well as yourself. You are a grown woman you should clean up after yourself.
Rule number 47 is just absolutely funny. Though I’ve never flatulated in front of my mother (that she is aware of at least) I do have a very funny story of her flatulating while giving me an angry "welcome to the family" hug. My brother-in-laws who were behind her tried so hard not to laugh, but as she kept loudly and quickly tooting one-right after the other like a machine gun they just couldn't hold the laughter back. She kept calm and cool and just acted as if nothing happened. I had to admire her for that.
I tried rule 11 once and it completely backfired on me. I don't think I will ever try it again. I completely disagree with rule number 32. To allow yourself harm because you are afraid of being honest with your MIL is ridiculous. There are nice ways to ask your MIL not to wear the perfume around you because it harms you. The same thing goes with rule number 69. Your baby and your baby’s health come first. Let her know smoking is NOT allowed in your home and especially not near the baby. There are no "ands, ifs or buts" about it. Your baby's health is more important than her feelings. If she is willing to chew some nicorette gum to deal with this, great but if not and she thinks your a fool and refuses to listen to you you need to stand up for you and your baby.
To improve the book I would like to see more rules on bigger issues. Many times it isn't the little issues but the big issues (ex: bigotry) that keep DILs and MILs from ever getting along. I don't think it’s a good idea to just nod your head and smile when racist remarks are made. Walk away or let it be known that racist remarks are not okay. You don't need to argue, but you don't have to stay and listen to them either. She needs to know those kind of remarks are not welcome around you or your family. Remember things she says can influence your children.
I would like to continue by stating that one of the reasons I could not agree with many of the rules in this book is because I cannot relate to it as well as I would have liked. The MIL character in this book just sounds absolutely terrible and disrespectful to her DIL. I mean she is out right mean. She puts her DIL down, curses at her and around her, makes hateful remarks, etc. On top of all that she is the type of woman that will invade your fridge with her dishes and throw yours out. I would never stand for that. Call me prideful, but I call it verbal abuse. I have my limits. When you disrespect me, my family or my home - you're out of there. My MIL can have her rude moments, worst in the past, but if she was ever like this character in this book I would not take it.
I am grateful that my MIL isn't like the one in the book.
For other points of view take a look at this video http://www.brightcove.tv/title.jsp?title=1732351772










